Two different football games (guest post)

This poem was originally published on Manny's blog.


Amongst the family homes

Besides the Merri Creek

No trains or trams in sight

The fans walk through the streets

They wander from their cars

And make their way inside

An old suburban ground

To watch their teams with pride

They join thousands on their feet

Not all can get a seat

They shiver in the cold

Just like the days of old

Down at the MCG

From comfortable modern stands

Far more go to see

Two clubs of foreign lands

Many chose to go

To simply see a show

And there are many more

To watch clubs that they adore

Those who’ve come in suits

are removed from the grassroots

There’s money to be made

And guests to entertain

Deep in Melbourne’s North

Two stories intertwine

One has stayed on top

One reversing their decline

They share a Balkan past

And a football rivalry

And a vision of the future

Gives this game vitality

National aspirations

Beckon both these clubs

A final game before they rise

A taste of what’s to come

The friendly down in Richmond

Is derided by some fans

Too soon after competition

To travel to far lands

The players are too tired

To put on a great show

Many chose to rest

With their families back at home

There’s no three points or silverware

No preseason insight

There’s not too much to play for

For either team tonight

Preston score in seconds

The stadium erupts

Their fans’ nerves dissipate

In a moment of triumph

The South fans are not happy

The urgency soon rises

Losing is not an option

For that there are no prizes

On the pitch each player rides

The passion from the stands

Each kick and tackle fueled by cheers

And jeers of all the fans

Clapping from the MCC

Some flags from fan clubs too

The neutrals of the MCG though

Aren’t sure what to do

A goal – that’s nice – another – cool

Half time substitutions

The first team players slowing down

Young players the solution

The intensity pedestrian

The fans can recognise

The goals don’t seem to matter

It’s a training exercise

Until the end of the first half

It’s tense at BT Connor

South score a goal to equalise

Half time comes soon after

The second half a change occurs

The teams come out much sharper

They’ve learnt their lessons from the first

This next half will be tougher

South go onto take the lead

But the Lions do bite back

The game hangs in the balance

Until South’s winning attack

The MCG goes onto see

And quiet second half

The final score, a one-one draw

Placates the fans and players and staff

To add some tension this can’t be

The solution much be penalties

The Aussie Kuol scores to see

Newcastle crowned the winning team

The fans saw Ange and Kuol and teams

They admire from afar

Many leave the game with smiles

They saw their superstars

The fans up north leave their game

Hungry for much more

A taste of what next year could be

Makes them insatiable

The work from volunteers

The patience of club fans

Was paid off back in spades

They can hope again

Across the country football fans

Tuned in uncertainly

But South and Preston showed in the end

What Australian football could be

Knights can’t catch a break but South can throw a goal (guest post)

This post was originally posted by Manny on his own blog

Well here we are again. I managed to pull myself to another South game this season between work, study and the rest of it. Funnily enough it happened to be the return leg of the my last attended match. I headed down to Knights Stadium with a few of the boys and couldn’t be happier with how I spent my Friday night. We parked in one of the side streets and managed to get a seat before kick off – beer and cevapi in hand!

The First Half was really just a warm up

Heading into the match, I think most people were pretty confident. South have been flying on top of the table (Avondale match aside) and have been scoring buckets of goals. Knights on the other hand are struggling this season and even recently replaced their coach with Ivan Franjic. South were expected to walk this one, but as is often the case, the match itself was never going to be so simple.

South did not start the game in a flurry of goals, but rather, seemed happy to sit back and watch Knights control the tempo in the first half. The Knights though couldn’t make the most of their possession and only really created in a few nerve racking goal square skirmishes.

South’s efforts with the ball on the other hand seemed few and far, with a number of direct plays on transition failing to generate any clear cut chances. South were borderline reckless with the ball in the first half and seemed to lack any attacking structure. Ball after ball would fly down the right wing, and the few times where it found its target there wasn’t anyone waiting in the box to complete the play.

Rain rain rain

As half time came to a close, the heavens opened up and completely obliterated any chance of neat football for the rest of the day. Thankfully though, the rain was coming in from behind the grandstand so everyone was kept dry (except for the mini-roos who were absolutely drenched during their half-time kick-about).

Although I was grateful to be in the stand I was surprised that I didn’t have any other choice. This was the first time I had been to Knights Stadium where only the main grand stand was open to spectators. I’m not sure why the terraces were closed on the night, but considering that the Knights won’t be joining us in the NST next year, I think there might be little reason for the full stadium to open in the near future…

Return to the status quo

In the second half South showed a lot more promise. The boys were holding onto the ball and controlling the tempo of the game. South looked to create more structured and less rushed build ups in addition to the occasional direct transition play. It was better to watch, but ironically, these less compact tactics actually allowed the Knights to create their most threatening opportunities of the game.

Lopez put in a man-of-the match performance in that second half alone and made a number of game changing saves to keep the Knights off the scoresheet. At the other end of the ground, it appeared only one thing was going to break the deadlock – once again a long throw was met by Lucas Inglese to put South up 1-0 and ultimately pinch the three points.

Knights Stadium: Where Chap Laps and Eurovision meet

We made our way out of the game relatively smoothly (and a little smugly as we walked by the slowly moving car park traffic), however not before appreciating the music over the stadium P.A. system. I can only assume the stadium DJ was heading out after the match, because the home team result was completely ignored in favour of an upbeat playlist that traversed EDM, Croatia’s Eurovision entry, and early 00’s dance hits.

I used to think South was alone in solidifying their golden years in this way, but just as Lakeside is always blasting 90’s and 00’s dance hits I was glad to see Knights had a similar energy. Rated it!

Knights and the NST

Compared to Lakeside, Knights Stadium offers much more for the football purists. I can’t help but envy the homeliness of their stadium and the better, closer view of the pitch. But a nice view doesn’t pay the bills, and looking around the Stadium you can understand why the Knights aren’t gambling on the NST next year.

Unlike Lakeside, Knights Stadium is managed by the club. This means the Knights need to source funds to maintain their huge property in addition to football operations. As we know these days, cash flow is hard to come by. I say this not to suggest that the Knight’s don’t have the financial capacity (I don’t know their arrangements well enough to assume that), but I say this to make the point that the club has far more financial obligations than other clubs and it is understandable why they would want to take a conservative stance in relation to the NST.

It will be a shame not to have the Knights in the NST next year. Fingers crossed the competition is a success and they can join in soon after its launch.

What else of the NST

Things have been unusually quiet. The FA have done a great job managing the public communications the process, specially in that they have been able to limit communication leaks. I think the most important things fans can do though is be aware of the FA’s stated process. Specifically:

• Formal proposal and bid submissions which are due in mid-April.
• The Assessment and Review (A&R) Phase is scheduled for April and May
• The Completion Phase will commence in June 2024.

This also explains why there were some public leaks in April (including the Knight’s negative statement) as this is when clubs were finalising their submissions.

So what next for the NST? Well, I suspect the few remaining clubs either know they are in and have no reason to leak news ahead of a group announcement, or they know they are out and have lost interest in public comments as a means of negotiation.

Perhaps the Preston vs South game will be used as a platform for an announcement (I doubt that) or perhaps the FA is waiting until after the A-League Grand Final. If you are really desperate you can listen in to the 3XY Sunday Soccer program for scraps of rumours but otherwise we simply have to wait.

South vs Preston

Let’s say this first. South already played the Knights in the cup and now that we are facing Preston I find it hard to believe anything other than the fact these fixtures are less than random. Regardless the game is happening, and I’ll be missing out for reasons of both study and nerves.

This is a danger game in more ways than one. On the pitch it could be a huge banana peel considering the team’s relative ladder positions. Having attended a few Preston games over the years I can confirm that South will also face a vocal and passionate crowd, unlike what they have seen for a while – and considering our performances in high pressure Grand Finals… I am not getting my hopes up.

Also – and for this reason I doubt the FA will make any NST announcements at the game – this match will be secured like an A-League match. Over 80 security staff and police are expected to be in attendance in addition to a number of other security measures. After the recent Preston vs Oakleigh game ended with a bit of fuss I’m inclined to think some heroes may try use this fixture for their own ultra-lite grandstanding, but I sincerely no incidents occur. Not just for the match itself, but considering these clubs are due to play each other a couple times a year in perpetuity, it would also bode poorly for the future prospects of this fixture.

Regardless, a sell out crowd is expected and I think many many people around the country will be keeping an eye on this match. Fingers crossed… let’s go South!

Postecoglou in Prahran – Again! – Kind of! – But also, actually maybe!

I can’t believe it’s happened but after reading two books about the man this year, watching a dozen games, and hours of press conferences I am finally ready to admit it… I am looking forward to a break from tracking Postecoglou for at least a few weeks.

Optus Sport, Tottenham have now completed their season and have done very well by securing 5th place. Please consider this note my explicit blessing for you to slow down your relentless Ange-posting, for at least three weeks.

Also, special mention to KeepUp’s efforts this season – this $30m platform was seemingly designed to report on Postecoglou’s career but amazingly couldn’t make this intriguing business case work, commiserations.

That said, there actually is a little bit of Ange news left to squeeze out this season. A paper mural had been erected in Prahran, just a stones throw away from Albert Park, and of course Tottenham will be coming to Melbourne this week! Will we see Ange at Lakeside?

Notes from the 2023 AGM

Dusting off the blog for a bit of AGM action, with the usual suspect mix of opinion and fact.

As usual, I'm not going to recount everything that was said; even taking into account that there were a number of people in the room, so nothing's really a secret, it was nevertheless a meeting for members, and not outsiders. Besides which, I don't want to potentially get the president (and by extension, the club) in trouble for commentary that the president would not have intended for a wider audience, ala the 2023 Christmas party comments which caused some angst within Football Victoria, and which is an issue which remains unresolved, even if pretty much everyone else has moved on.

Amazingly, I had nothing to do with that, which probably says something about the state of the blog in its dying days as a regular ongoing concern. But back to the AGM. One could cavil with me putting out anything - at least some people usually do - and they may have a point. But some members would not or could not attend, but they still have, I think, a right to understand the broader state of the club and its future direction, especially with the National Second Division coming up.

Attendance-wise, things looked grim approaching the designated starting time, but it gradually improved to if not a great number, than at least to something approaching not completely unacceptable. The timing and notice provided of our AGMs is becoming even more ordinary than usual, which certainly has an impact; as does expecting our supporters to come into Lakeside twice in two days, especially midweek. 

Anyway, the meeting began with a presentation of the financials, and what can one say about that? Presented on the big screen via a scrolling PDF instead of the usual PowerPoint presentation (which says something about how even a delayed AGM didn't have complete preparation), we were told that there was increase in turnover from $1.8 million to $2.1 million (largely due to inflation), and a modest surplus of about $26,000, well down on some of the previous years' efforts. As noted in the post for the 2022 AGM, there was a plan to write off the director loans, and that has been done.

It was noted that the juniors more or less break even, and that the women's program is close to breaking even, observations that get trotted out at most AGMs. There was passing mention that at some stage in the past money from the juniors had been used to cover the costs of the senior men, without specifying a year. Considering that the juniors were a separate entity before the reunification - what was it, 2009 - one wonders what year exactly was that passing reference to? 

Mention was made of the most recent jersey night, which was held in the upstairs function room rather than in the social club. Some passing mention of a 40th anniversary celebration for the 1984 championship, the celebration of the 10th anniversary of the 2014 title, and a testimonial night for Brad Norton. I'm not holding out much hope for any of these things happening, not only because it takes a lot of work to put nights like that together, but also because for years now the South Melbourne Hellas social calendar includes so few events for the ordinary fan. The jersey night is strictly for the sponsors. Apart from the Christmas get together, there's nothing outside match day to gather the ordinary supporter to Lakeside. No trivia nights, no presentation nights, no family days.

Lakeside Stadium's location contributes to what might be called a lack of a feeling of "civil society". Where is the evidence of the club being a shared experience? There's still a South fan forum which exists outside the remit of the club, but it functions as both a social and technological relic. I suppose you could extrapolate that to what the club is as a whole. Come to an occasional game, and you've performed your, for lack of a better term, civic duty to the club. This follows on to things like volunteerism, which sees a thin pool from which to draw volunteers.

The organisation and operation of the club is incredibly top heavy. Much of the sponsorship of the club is connected to the personal networks fostered by the president. Much of the day to day operation of the club is down to individual directors and board members, when it should be the job of people working for the club in paid roles. Merch, media, meetings with outside organisations and stakeholders - it shouldn't be up to people taking time out of their day jobs to do this stuff.

And thus moving to the National Second Division (finally), this is one of my concerns - how does the club plan to scale up its operations, and can it scale up quickly enough and to an appropriate level? When you think about it, getting the on field bit sorted is the easy part. You'll be in a higher division, and you'll naturally attract better playing talent. But to avoid this becoming the dreaded "NPL on planes", you've got to be much better across the board. You've got to offer a better fan experience, a better media experience, a better sponsor experience, etc. I might be (and was) shouted down for commenting that we're only getting about 200 people to most games - but the point I wanted to make before being interrupted was that we struggle to amass volunteers and promptly feed people under our current circumstances, and that if the plan is to be regularly getting 1500 people to a game, then things will need to change. 

To be fair to the board and especially the president, they are aware of the issue of being a top-heavy organisation. And to be fair to our board, this is not only a South Melbourne problem. Just about every club that plans to be in the NSD is going to face a massive cultural and organisational adjustment, where throwing a bunch of money at problems will not address them. The prospective NSD clubs will not only have to begin employing (more) non-match day related staff, but also setting strategies for the new day-to-day staff to implement, to make their club, the new league, and the game better. If you're a budding sports business graduate, there might be a few roles opening up - though our club says it has developed short lists of people it would like to hire for certain roles.

People bring up money and crowds, and that's certainly a huge part of it. Quite how South (and some of the other clubs) end up funding the this thing in year one, two, and then afterwards has always been a central concern. And for our part, there were a number of possibilities thrown out about how that might come about - increased membership and attendance, both necessary, can only do so much. Broadcast deals which see money come into the league are a long way away. So it's going to come down to sponsorship, and perhaps even that dreaded term - part-privatisation. 

As part of the NSD planning, the club has to figure out how the new NSD sub-entity, operating underneath the SMH umbrella as SMFC does now, will operate. And one of the ideas floated - though not necessarily the preferred option - would be a part (up to 49%) privatisation of the SMFC NSD entity. It was made clear, however, that our members would have to approve such a move. In terms of operating budgets, the club will have to double its current turnover. When asked about how confident it was in its financial forecasting, the president said that the board had allowed a fair bit of fat in its anticipated costings.

But apart from finances, the NSD will also require major changes to how these clubs run themselves, and how they fit into something larger than themselves. Say what you will about the A-League and the APL cartel, but for the most part cartel discipline within that organisation has been strong. And I think we can say that, despite the seeming commonality of purpose that a variety of clubs have maintained to get to this point, that sense of common purpose will only now start to be properly tested. Up to now, it has mostly been talking about desire. Now desire has the chance to become reality, and that's a lot messier.

And what the NSD looks like is sill up in the air. Can we get to at least ten clubs across at least three states? Putting aside concerns about the viability of any of the current NSD eight, will any new additions be merely desperate add-ons just to the get comp over the line? Having the indefinite bank guarantees is great for providing peace of mind, but you'd of course rather not need them.

There's going to have to be a massive cultural change. The role of the board will have to be streamlined, taking it from a DIY set-up to a strategy and delegating operation. The plan is also to have all board members become directors. The club will have to at some point become financially independent from the sponsor networks nurtured by Nick Maikousis. Regardless of whatever happens with the NSD, the club has to become a re-generative operation - it needs new fans, new sponsors, new volunteers At the moment, it is atrophying. You'd hate to think that the NSD is the club's last chance to permanently turn things around, to make Lakeside a destination venue instead of something to avoid, but it's hard to see it otherwise. 

This AGM also marked the end of the board electoral cycle. The board positions of SMH and SMFC were vacated, and the current board members were reinstated unopposed. I will also note that the questions asked by the members in attendance were sophisticated, insightful, and a credit to those participating. For all the accusations of negativity that I might be accused of, it's never (or seldom) done out of spite. It's because I care about the club, and I don't want to see it die. While it wasn't a huge attendance, those present at the AGM clearly feel the same way, and their care and interest provided a degree of hope.

Lastly, a massive thanks to Ian, a member in attendance at the AGM, who let me know before the meeting how much South of the Border had meant to him as a South fan - even if he didn't always agree with the match analysis!